Why I am Nervous but Hopeful about the New Archbishop of Canterbury

“So the Church of England has appointed another middle aged, white, anti-gay guy to be the 105th Archbishop of Canterbury. Big whoop.” This is how Emergent theoblogger Tony Jones describes the appointment of Justin Welby as Archbishop. I kind of have to agree with him even though I’m an Anglican priest. I’m actually kind of nervous, but yet with a glimmer of hope.
First my anxieties. Like Jones said he’s white, male, older and anti gay. Add to this the fact that he’s from a wealthy, privileged, well connected family and a former oil executive and he doesn’t look very promising. He has distanced himself from his oil industry days and says that his view on gay marriage is evolving. One of the knocks on him that I don’t necessarily agree with is that he is too inexperienced for the position. Perhaps this lack of experience will help him to not stagnate in what has been a very blah post.
On a positive note he does support the consecration of  female bishops. That won’t win him any friends in some circles but it does give him some credibility in the public sphere. His appointment may be just the thing that nudges the English church toward allowing women bishops.
Then there are my problems with the process. He’s appointed not elected and to this lowly priest it smacks of back room dealing. How about a little more democratic input?  Then there is the one thing about the anglican church that bugs me: we’re still pretty much a state church, at least the CofE is. The Prime Minister is involved, as well as bureaucrats, and then there is our beloved head of the church, the Queen. Don’t get me started on the queen!!!
I also have some hesitations about the position itself. For one thing the archbishop lives in a palace. I’ve never been there but I’m sure a flat could do. I’m also not sure of the role and significance of the Canterbury see. And I am especially nervous about folks who want the Archbishop of Canterbury to act like a Pope. There is really no power here and if the primary reason for the post is unity, well I’m not sure that can work anymore. But the hardest question I have is what does Justin Welby or anyone else as Archbishop of Canterbury have to do with ministry at the local parish level?
All that aside I am willing to give Welby a chance, although its not a job that I covet. He has his work cut out for him. Let’s pray for wisdom for him and patience for us.

5 thoughts on “Why I am Nervous but Hopeful about the New Archbishop of Canterbury

  1. Would it be alright if the new Archbishop of Canterbury was in his twenties? I don’t get the “middle-aged” criticism. Surely the position calls for someone with a bit of life experience. Also, would it be okay if he was black and anti-gay (that was one of the options)? So if you are white, male, over a certain age and, gasp, CONSERVATIVE, it seems the knives have already been sharpened. Intolerance comes in many forms.

    1. Well the middle aged thing is the least of my concerns. In reality he’s not that old, especially for this type of office. I don’t think its intolerant to point out your concerns with the person being appointed to such a high profile post. Let’s face it old, white mean don’t have a good track record of running much of anything, and I say that as a rapidly aging white male. You’re right that none of the other perspective candidates were any better. It could be that Welby is the right person for the job. I’m willing to give him a chance.

  2. My point is let’s give him a chance rather than dismiss him because of the selection process, his age, his skin colour, his gender or his theological leanings. With respect to old, white men, I think Winston Churchill, Abraham Lincoln, and F. D. Roosevelt were quite great leaders. All white. All men. All “old”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s